AC1 "The Shady Dragon Inn" is replete with errors, partly owing to alternate reference to B/X or BECMI rules, but also involving simple arithmetic. This undermines the supplement's usefulness as a quick source of NPCs, since every stat needs to be double-checked.
Numbers in parentheses mean one of two things: if found in the armor class of the character, they show the adjusted armor class when he or she is wearing a magical protection device. If found in the saving throws of characters who have high Wisdom, they show the adjustment for magical attack.
The Shady Dragon Inn (1983)
Fighters:
#6 Eric the Honest should be level 4-6 (not 2) for saving throws and THACO to be accurate (hp 31 suggests level 5); AL is given as "4"
Magic-Users:
Spells listed probably represent those memorized, not those contained in spell books (only one character is listed with read magic, known by all magic-users in BECMI).
B/X (top) vs. BECMI 1st printing (bottom) magic-user spell progression
#27 Deidre Hrolfsdottir is correctly listed as AC 9(8) with Dex 13
#30 Gregor Grimmin is correctly listed as AC 10 with Dex 7, without parentheses
#31 Horatius the Woad is correctly listed as AC 9(10) with Dex 7
#36 Paulinus Ravenfriend has an extra 1st level spell (read magic), otherwise B/X or BECMI 1st ed. spell progression
#37 Rhys the Quick has an extra 1st level spell, otherwise B/X or BECMI 1st ed. spell progression
#38 Selina of the Black Coast should be AC 11(10) (not 9(10) with Dex penalty and ring of protection +1; has BECMI saving throws, B/X THACO progression, and B/X or BECMI 1st ed. spell progression
#40 Umberto the Ugly has BECMI saving throws, B/X THACO progression, and B/X spell progression
#42 Zarkon the Blue save vs. wands should be 11 (not 12); is level 7, but has BECMI 1st/2nd ed. level 8 spell progression
Magic-users have BECMI (same in both 1st and 2nd ed.) saving throws,* B/X THACO progression, and B/X spell progression (with a couple of errors)
*not adjusted for those with a ring of protection, with one exception
Clerics:
B/X (top) vs. BECMI 1st printing (bottom) cleric spell progression
#48 Friar Fergus has BECMI spell progression
#49 Humbert the Large save vs. wands should be 10 (not 9), THACO should be 18 (not 19) using mace +1 with Str penalty
#50 Jerome the Holy has BECMI spell progression
Thieves:
#64 Fenris the Filch RT should be 30% (not 40%); THACO includes weapon bonus?
#69 Lenore the Beautiful THACO should be 15 (not 13) with Str penalty
#71 Olwynn White-Hand THACO should be 13 (not 11) with Str bonus
#72 Sara of the Slight Touch THACO should be 9 (not 7) with Str bonus
#73 Zacharias the Nimble THACO should be 13 (not 11) with Str penalty
Thieves have BECMI saving throws (same in both 1st and 2nd ed.), B/X THACO progression (with several errors), and B/X or BECMI 1st ed. (identical) skill chances (with a few errors).
Dwarves:
#78 Hugi Tunneltrue save vs. spells should be 12 (not 11) with Wis penalty
#79 Ifor, Hill-Lord Dex should be 13 (not 3) for AC 1
#79-83 have BECMI (revised/2nd ed.) save vs. spells
Dwarves have BECMI (revised/2nd ed.) saving throws, and B/X THACO progression.
Elves:
Elves have BECMI (revised/2nd ed.) saving throws, B/X THACO progression, and B/X or BECMI 1st ed. (identical) spell progression.
Halflings:
#105 Wat Watershed should be AC 2 (not 3) with Dex bonus
Halflings have BECMI (revised/2nd ed.) saving throws, and B/X THACO progression.
Special Characters:
Figgen - BECMI 2nd ed saving throws, B/X THACO progression (doesn't account for Str bonus)
Peralay - BECMI 2nd ed saving throws, B/X THACO progression (doesn't account for Str bonus), B/X spell progression, but is missing a 5th level spell
Elkhorn - BECMI 2nd ed. saving throws, BECMI THACO progression
Ringlerun - AC with ring +1, B/X THACO progression, B/X or BECMI spell progression, but with extra 2nd level spell
Strongheart - BECMI saving throws (save vs. spells doesn't take into account Wis bonus), BECMI THACO progression
Zargash - BECMI saving throws, THACO should be 18 (not 19), BECMI spell progression
Zarak - BECMI saving throws, RT should be 30% (not 40%), BX or BECMI 1st ed. thief skill progression
Kelek - AC with ring of protection +1, save vs. spells should be 11 (not 12) with Wis bonus
Raven - BECMI saving throws, B/X THACO progression
Warduke - BECMI THACO progression
No comments:
Post a Comment