Sunday, October 9, 2022

AC1: Errata

AC1 "The Shady Dragon Inn" is replete with errors, partly owing to alternate reference to B/X or BECMI rules, but also involving simple arithmetic.  This undermines the supplement's usefulness as a quick source of NPCs, since every stat needs to be double-checked.

Numbers in parentheses mean one of two things: if found in the armor class of the character, they show the adjusted armor class when he or she is wearing a magical protection device. If found in the saving throws of characters who have high Wisdom, they show the adjustment for magical attack.

The Shady Dragon Inn (1983)


AC is not given with adjusted AC in parenthesis in most cases (the only exceptions are in the magic-user section), and saving throws are modified to account for high Wisdom, not given with the adjusted value in parenthesis, (or adjusted for characters with a ring of protection).


Fighters:

#4 Charles the Bold should have a THACO of 18 (not 16) with a Str 15
#5 Donal of Clear Water should be AC 4 (not 8) for chain mail + Dex bonus; should have a THACO 18 (not 16) with a Str 15
#6 Eric the Honest should be level 4-6 (not 2) for saving throws and THACO to be accurate (hp 31 suggests level 5); AL is given as "4"
#7 Fiona has a sword +7 (likely +1)
#9 Harold Forkbeard should be AC 6 (not 4) for chain mail + Dex penalty
#9-15, 17-18 have BECMI (revised/2nd ed.) saving throws, but B/X THACO progression
#20-22 sword +7 (likely +1)

Fighters have BECMI (revised/2nd ed.) saving throws, and B/X THACO progression.


Magic-Users:

Spells listed probably represent those memorized, not those contained in spell books (only one character is listed with read magic, known by all magic-users in BECMI).


B/X (top) vs. BECMI 1st printing (bottom) magic-user spell progression


#24 Apris the Wondrous should be AC 10 (not 9) with Dex 7
#27 Deidre Hrolfsdottir is correctly listed as AC 9(8) with Dex 13
#30 Gregor Grimmin is correctly listed as AC 10 with Dex 7, without parentheses
#31 Horatius the Woad is correctly listed as AC 9(10) with Dex 7
#32 Jasper the White is correctly listed as AC 9(10) with Dex 8
#36 Paulinus Ravenfriend has an extra 1st level spell (read magic), otherwise B/X or BECMI 1st ed. spell progression
#37 Rhys the Quick has an extra 1st level spell, otherwise B/X or BECMI 1st ed. spell progression
#38 Selina of the Black Coast should be AC 11(10) (not 9(10) with Dex penalty and ring of protection +1; has BECMI saving throws, B/X THACO progression, and B/X or BECMI 1st ed. spell progression
#39 Tomas Tarn has BECMI saving throws, B/X THACO progression, and BECMI 1st/2nd ed. spell progression, although is missing a 4th level spell
#40 Umberto the Ugly has BECMI saving throws, B/X THACO progression, and B/X spell progression
#42 Zarkon the Blue save vs. wands should be 11 (not 12); is level 7, but has BECMI 1st/2nd ed. level 8 spell progression

Magic-users have BECMI (same in both 1st and 2nd ed.) saving throws,* B/X THACO progression, and B/X spell progression (with a couple of errors)

*not adjusted for those with a ring of protection, with one exception


Clerics:


B/X (top) vs. BECMI 1st printing (bottom) cleric spell progression


#47 Egbert Swordbreaker has BECMI saving throws
#48 Friar Fergus has BECMI spell progression
#49 Humbert the Large save vs. wands should be 10 (not 9), THACO should be 18 (not 19) using mace +1 with Str penalty
#50 Jerome the Holy has BECMI spell progression
#51-59 have BECMI saving throws, B/X THACO progression, and BECMI spell progression
#54 Nestor the Wise has an extra 5th level spell
#56 Penelope of West Haven should have AC 2 (not 3) for plate mail/shield, is missing two 3rd level spells and has an extra 4th level spell

Clerics have BECMI (same in both 1st and 2nd ed.) saving throws, B/X THACO progression, and BECMI spell progression (with a couple of errors)


Thieves:

#60 Aiden Ablefingers should be AC 8 (not 6) for Dex bonus alone
#62 Celeste the Swift OL should be 25% (not 20%) and PP 30% (not 25%)
#64 Fenris the Filch RT should be 30% (not 40%); THACO includes weapon bonus?
#65 Gwynne Cutpurse HS should be 35% (not 36%)
#68 Katie Cruell HS should be 65% (not 75%)
#69 Lenore the Beautiful THACO should be 15 (not 13) with Str penalty
#70 Miles the Highwayman THACO should be 15 (not 13) with Str penalty
#71 Olwynn White-Hand THACO should be 13 (not 11) with Str bonus
#72 Sara of the Slight Touch THACO should be 9 (not 7) with Str bonus
#73 Zacharias the Nimble THACO should be 13 (not 11) with Str penalty

Thieves have BECMI saving throws (same in both 1st and 2nd ed.), B/X THACO progression (with several errors), and B/X or BECMI 1st ed. (identical) skill chances (with a few errors).


Dwarves:

#77 Eben of Whitemount save vs. spells should be 10 (not 9)
#78 Hugi Tunneltrue save vs. spells should be 12 (not 11) with Wis penalty
#79 Ifor, Hill-Lord Dex should be 13 (not 3) for AC 1
#79-83 have BECMI (revised/2nd ed.) save vs. spells

Dwarves have BECMI (revised/2nd ed.) saving throws, and B/X THACO progression.


Elves:

#84 Aithne of Far Isle save vs. MW should be 13 (not 3)
#85 Aneurin of the Oak should be AC 6 (not 7) with Dex penalty
#86 Blaise Barkbreaker should be AC 2 (not 3) with Dex bonus, also speaks Orc, but elves already speak Gnoll, Hobgoblin, and Orc
#87 Cathal of Greendale save vs. spells should be 10 (not 11) with Wis bonus
#94 Rorie the Red is missing a 5th level spell

Elves have BECMI (revised/2nd ed.) saving throws, B/X THACO progression, and B/X or BECMI 1st ed. (identical) spell progression.


Halflings:

#99 Dorcas Deepdelver should have a THACO of 18 (not 16) with a Str 6
#105 Wat Watershed should be AC 2 (not 3) with Dex bonus

Halflings have BECMI (revised/2nd ed.) saving throws, and B/X THACO progression.


Special Characters:

Mercion - BECMI saving throws, B/X spell progression
Figgen - BECMI 2nd ed saving throws, B/X THACO progression (doesn't account for Str bonus)
Peralay - BECMI 2nd ed saving throws, B/X THACO progression (doesn't account for Str bonus), B/X spell progression, but is missing a 5th level spell
Elkhorn - BECMI 2nd ed. saving throws, BECMI THACO progression
Ringlerun - AC with ring +1, B/X THACO progression, B/X or BECMI spell progression, but with extra 2nd level spell
Strongheart - BECMI saving throws (save vs. spells doesn't take into account Wis bonus), BECMI THACO progression

Fox Fingers - BECMI saving throws, THACO 7 too low (even with a Str 18), B/X or BECMI 1st ed. thief skill progression
Zargash - BECMI saving throws, THACO should be 18 (not 19), BECMI spell progression
Zarak - BECMI saving throws, RT should be 30% (not 40%), BX or BECMI 1st ed. thief skill progression
Skylla - AC with ring of protection +1, BECMI saving throws
Kelek - AC with ring of protection +1, save vs. spells should be 11 (not 12) with Wis bonus
Raven - BECMI saving throws, B/X THACO progression
Warduke - BECMI THACO progression

Special characters have BECMI (2nd ed.) saving throws, either B/X or BECMI THACO progression, B/X or BECMI spell progression, and B/X or BECMI 1st ed. thief skill progression.

No comments:

Post a Comment